Krueger: Brewers Title Means Either 'Historic Civic Pride' Or 'Elaborate Voter Suppression'

A retired DPW supervisor weighs the World Series championship against Tuesday's election and declines to pick a side.

Stadium Celebrations: A Moment of Victory
Downtown revelers Friday night, a data point of uncertain significance to Tuesday's turnout. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — The Milwaukee Brewers won the World Series on Friday night, five days before Wisconsin's general election, and I have spent the subsequent 72 hours trying to determine whether that is good news or bad news for democracy. I have not reached a conclusion, which I recognize is not the normal function of an analysis column, but I did not spend 31 years in the city Department of Public Works telling people a pothole was smaller than it was, and I am not going to start telling people a civic question is simpler than it is.

The question, stated plainly, is this: does a once-in-a-generation championship five days before an election produce a surge of civic pride that carries straight through to the ballot box, or does it produce a four-day bar-based fugue state from which Waukesha County does not fully emerge until sometime after Thanksgiving?

Two Competing Theories, Neither Disprovable

Theory one holds that a championship of this magnitude generates a sense of collective civic identity, that a county already feeling good about itself shows up to vote in that same spirit, riding the parade energy straight into the polling place. Theory two holds that the entire county is currently too busy processing a title 40-odd years in the making to think about school board races, and that whatever energy exists is being spent exclusively on reliving Friday's ninth inning, repeatedly, at volume, in bars.

I called the Waukesha County Clerk's office to ask which theory their early numbers supported. A spokesperson named Darlene Hofstetter told me the office does not track voter mood, only voter turnout, and that if I wanted to know whether Tuesday's numbers were suppressed by baseball, I would need to wait for the final count and then argue about it afterward like everyone else. I told her that was not a satisfying answer. She agreed it was not, but said it was the only one she had.

"It's either the year civic pride peaked in this county, or the year we found the single most effective distraction from civic participation ever recorded. I don't think we get to know which until it's over."

— Bob Krueger, opinion contributor

The Bar Congestion Variable

I drove past three separate establishments on Friday night attempting to estimate crowd density for this column and gave up after the third, a tavern on the east side where the line for the bathroom had, by my count, reached the front window. If that level of congestion persists through the weekend, and I have no reason to believe it will not, I am prepared to estimate bar capacity in this county at something north of 125 percent of normal, a figure I am aware is not physically possible and am including anyway because it felt true standing there.

I also want to flag, in the interest of full transparency, that I have heard from two separate sources that an unspecified number of evening poll workers have already requested Tuesday off, citing what one termed 'championship recovery.' I have not been able to confirm a number with the clerk's office, and Hofstetter would only say that staffing 'remains adequate at this time,' a phrase I have learned to treat with the same skepticism I once reserved for contractors who told me a culvert repair would hold through winter.

Where I Land, For Now

History suggests the county will spend the next several months assigning retroactive meaning to whatever Tuesday's turnout number turns out to be, the same way 2022's numbers were eventually credited to redistricting, gas prices, and, in one letter to the editor I still think about, the condition of Sunset Drive. If turnout is high, the championship will be cited as proof that a proud county shows up. If turnout is low, the championship will be cited as proof that a county can only hold one piece of good news in its head at a time. Both explanations will be offered with total confidence by people who have not looked at a single underlying number.

For what it's worth, I have already voted, and I did it Tuesday afternoon, before the Series was even decided, specifically so I would not have to find out which theory applied to me personally. I'd encourage everyone else to do the same, though at this point I recognize the encouragement is arriving somewhat late, and possibly into a bar.

Share this story: