'Best Of The Best' Voting Opens; Businesses Launch 'Coordinated' Campaigns
Waukesha County's annual contest kicked off Wednesday, triggering a monthlong surge of targeted vote-for-us posts across local social media feeds.
WAUKESHA — Voting opened Wednesday in the Best of the Best of Waukesha County contest, and within hours local business owners had settled into the familiar rhythm of asking, reminding, and occasionally begging their customers to vote, a pattern that will now run through the end of December.
The contest, which covers more than 40 categories from best pizza to best dry cleaner, draws thousands of votes each year and has become, for many business owners, a second full-time marketing job that nobody applied for.
"We sat down Tuesday night and mapped out the whole month," said Carl Oberbeck, 44, co-owner of a sandwich shop on East Avenue competing in the Best Sandwich Shop category for the fourth consecutive year. "Monday is the sincere post. Wednesday is the funny post. Friday is the post where we tag three other businesses and ask them to vote for us back." Oberbeck said his team debated for roughly 20 minutes Tuesday night over whether handing out free ballpoint pens printed with a QR code linking to the ballot would "ethically cross a line." They decided it would not, and ordered 500 pens Wednesday morning.
A changed feed
Renata Kowalczyk, 38, owner of a bakery near the courthouse square entered in Best Bakery and Best Cupcake, estimated that 60 to 70 percent of her business's social media output between now and December 31 will consist of some version of a voting reminder.
"It's not that I don't love my customers," Kowalczyk said. "It's that I have posted the words 'please vote for us' so many times this week that autocomplete finishes the sentence for me now." Kowalczyk said she tracks her daily vote count on a dry-erase board in the kitchen, updated each morning before the ovens go on, and that the board currently reads "Day 3 of 29."
"Participation this year is strong and diverse across retail, food service, and professional categories."
— Greater Waukesha Chamber of Commerce, in a statement
The Chamber of Commerce, which helps promote the contest but does not run the voting itself, said in a statement that this year's turnout appears on pace with 2025, though the organization does not release category-by-category vote totals until the contest closes.
The coordination problem
What has changed in recent years, several business owners said, is the degree of visible coordination among competitors within the same category, who increasingly follow, like, and comment on each other's voting posts in what amounts to a tacit nonaggression pact.
Dale Pribnow, 52, who runs an auto detailing business on Sunset Drive and is competing in Best Auto Detailing against two other shops, said the three owners have an informal understanding not to directly criticize each other's work in their campaign posts, limiting themselves instead to vague references to "quality you can see for yourself."
"We're all in the group chat," Pribnow said. "It's mostly about whether the voting link is working that day. Sometimes it goes down for an hour and all three of us panic at the same time.
Pen logistics
Back at the sandwich shop, Oberbeck said the 500 ballpoint pens, ordered through an online retailer and expected to arrive by Friday, will be handed out with any purchase through the end of the month rather than mailed or left unattended on the counter, which he said was the detail that ultimately satisfied his staff's ethics concerns. He declined to say which pen model (paid link) his shop ordered, calling it "proprietary to the campaign."
Kowalczyk, for her part, said she has no plans to hand out promotional items, preferring to rely on "an aggressive but tasteful" posting schedule and a single in-store sign reading "Vote For Us, We'll Know If You Don't." She said the sign is a joke. She also said three customers have asked her this week whether it is a joke.
Voting in the Best of the Best of Waukesha County contest remains open through December, with winners typically announced in early January.
