Waukesha South's Latest Loss Leaves Postgame Crowds Unusually Reserved
The Blackshirts' defeat prompted quiet contemplation at neighborhood burger joints and sports bars rather than the usual grumbling.
WAUKESHA — Waukesha South's football team lost again Friday night, falling 27-6 to drop to 1-7 overall and 0-5 in Parkland Conference play, and the usual postgame griping at South Street's burger joints and sports bars gave way to something quieter: people just sort of staring at their food.
At Chet's Char House, a burger counter three blocks from the high school that has served as an unofficial postgame gathering spot for Blackshirts fans since 1994, the normal rhythm of loud complaints about play-calling was absent by 9:40 p.m. Regulars instead ate in near silence, several checking their phones for Wisconsin Badgers news instead of rehashing the game.
"We've lost worse," said Keith Dombrowski, 58, a Chet's regular for eleven years who orders the same double cheeseburger and onion rings every Friday the team plays at home. "This one just felt like nobody had anything left to say about it. Usually somebody's mad about the fourth-down call. Tonight nobody brought it up."
Dombrowski said he tried, without much success, to redirect the table's attention. "I said, well, the Badgers play next week, so at least we have that," he said. "Got a couple nods. That was about it."
A Quieter Kind Of Loss
Three doors down at Full Count, a sports bar on South Street with eleven televisions and a trivia night every other Tuesday, manager Patty Oelschlager said she noticed the shift almost as soon as the final whistle blew on the bar's main screen.
"Normally there's yelling, somebody wants to talk to a manager about the officiating, somebody's blaming the offensive line," Oelschlager said. "Tonight it was just quiet. Polite, but deflated. Like everybody already knew."
"We switched four of the screens to the Badgers volleyball highlights around 9:15, and honestly, attendance at those screens went up. People wanted something that felt like it was going somewhere."
— Patty Oelschlager, manager, Full Count
Oelschlager said she pulled up the highlights after a regular asked, unprompted, whether the bar had "anything else going on," and said the request wasn't unusual on a night like this one. Full Count's kitchen also reported selling 22 fewer orders of the loaded nachos than a typical Friday home game, which Oelschlager attributed to "people just not being that hungry for it."
Record Now 0-5 In New Conference
Friday's loss was South's fifth straight defeat in Parkland Conference play since the league's formation this season from the former Western Division of the Woodland Conference, a reorganization that was supposed to give the Blackshirts a more competitive schedule. Athletic director Carl Fenstermacher's office did not respond to a request for comment on the team's conference record, but the school's official statement, issued through a spokesperson, noted only that "the coaching staff remains committed to the program's long-term development."
At Chet's, 71-year-old booth regular Arlene Petrashek said she's been coming to the burger counter after South games since her youngest son played linebacker there in the late 1980s, and called Friday's mood "the quietest I can remember since maybe 2016."
"Back then at least people were angry," Petrashek said. "Angry means you still care enough to yell. Tonight it was more like everybody already did the math on the season and decided not to talk about it out loud."
Next Up: North
South's next game is a road matchup, and several patrons at both Chet's and Full Count said, without much enthusiasm, that they planned to watch anyway. Oelschlager said Full Count would keep at least one screen on football "out of respect," but confirmed the bar has already blocked out screen time for Badgers postseason coverage regardless of how the Blackshirts' game unfolds.
Dombrowski said he'd be at Chet's next Friday as usual, double cheeseburger and onion rings, whatever the score. "Somebody's got to sit there," he said. "Might as well be me."
