Waukesha Man Turning 100 Mistaken For Brewers Superfan By Visiting News Crews
Walter Kowalczyk's birthday happened to land during the World Series, and reporters have been showing up expecting a baseball story.
WAUKESHA — Walter Kowalczyk turns 100 years old on Thursday, a fact that has become strangely difficult to communicate to the three television crews who have shown up at his daughter's house on Hartwell Avenue this week expecting to talk about the Milwaukee Brewers.
Kowalczyk, a retired tool-and-die machinist who has lived in Waukesha since 1958, says he has answered some version of the same question seven times since Monday: what does it feel like to watch the Brewers play for a championship at the same time he's turning 100?
"I tell them it feels fine, because those two things aren't related," Kowalczyk said Tuesday, seated in a recliner roughly four feet from a television that was, at the time, airing a cooking competition rather than baseball. "The birthday was booked in August. Nobody knew about any World Series in August."
A Banner Appears
The confusion appears to have started Monday morning, when a reporter and a photographer arrived expecting to find, in the words of the assignment note later shown to the family, "a 100-year-old lifelong super fan timing his birthday to the World Series." What they found instead was a man who follows the Brewers the normal amount for someone who has lived in Wisconsin for 68 years, and a birthday banner that happened to be yellow and navy because those were the balloon colors available at the Pick 'n Save on Sunset Drive.
Kowalczyk's daughter, Donna Prellwitz, 71, said she tried to clarify the situation on camera but the crew kept the footage anyway, cutting from Kowalczyk blowing out a candle directly to archival video of the Brewers celebrating a double play.
"I said, 'He's not really a superfan, he just likes it when they win same as everybody,' and they used maybe four seconds of that and forty seconds of him in a Brewers hat we put on him for the photo."
— Donna Prellwitz, daughter
The hat, for the record, was purchased Monday afternoon at a Walgreens for the express purpose of having something baseball-adjacent for the first crew to photograph, after which it became part of the ongoing bit for every subsequent crew.
Correcting The Record
Prellwitz said she has now given the same three-sentence clarification to each outlet that has called: the birthday party was planned in May, the venue was booked in July, the cake was ordered in August, and none of those dates involved anyone predicting a Brewers postseason run that would still be alive on October 29. She said most reporters nod, thank her, and ask the same superfan question again roughly ninety seconds later anyway.
Kowalczyk's grandson, Peter Prellwitz, 42, who flew in from Appleton for the party, said the family has started referring to the situation internally as "the overlap," and has stopped correcting people outside the house entirely.
"At this point we just let it ride. If someone wants to believe Grandpa planned his hundredth birthday around a baseball schedule nobody controls, that's honestly a more interesting story than the truth, which is he just wanted cake and to see everybody."
— Peter Prellwitz, grandson
The Actual Plan
The party itself, scheduled for Thursday afternoon at St. Mary's Hall, will seat roughly 60 relatives and friends, feature a cake from Larsen's Bakery, and include a slideshow of 94 photographs that Prellwitz assembled over the summer, none of which involve baseball. A card table near the entrance will hold a single television playing the World Series on mute, which Prellwitz described as "a concession, not a theme."
Kowalczyk said he does plan to watch the game that night, after the party ends, the same as he watches most Brewers games, and that he would be similarly willing to discuss the Packers, the weather, or his opinion on the downtown one-way streets if any reporter preferred a different angle. As of Tuesday evening, no one had taken him up on it.
"I turned 99 last year and nobody came," Kowalczyk said. "I'm not complaining. I'm just saying it's a strange year to suddenly be interesting."
