County Finds $4.6 Million Budget Error During Mid-Year Review, Calls Emergency Meeting

A misplaced decimal point in property tax revenue projections went unnoticed for eight months before this week's reconciliation review caught it.

Organizing Documents
A property tax revenue worksheet, the kind that can hide a decimal point for the better part of a year. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — County auditors conducting this week's quarterly reconciliation review found a $4.6 million error in the property tax revenue projection used to build the current fiscal year's budget, a mistake traced to a single misplaced decimal point that had gone uncorrected for roughly eight months. The county has called an emergency board meeting for Friday morning to address it.

The error surfaced Tuesday afternoon, when a junior auditor named Phil Grusczynski was cross-checking the revenue baseline against the prior year's figures and noticed the projected number was off by a factor of ten in one line of a 40-tab spreadsheet. Grusczynski said he initially assumed he was the one who had made a mistake and spent 45 minutes re-running his own math before flagging it to a supervisor.

Few Specifics From The County

A spokesperson for the Waukesha County Controller's Office, Renata Pilch, declined to specify which budgetary lines were affected by the error or whether it would require reallocating funds already approved for the year. "We're aware of the discrepancy and we're treating it with the seriousness it deserves," Pilch said in a two-sentence statement that did not use the word "error" and referred to the $4.6 million gap only as "a variance identified during routine review."

Pilch would not say how far along the fiscal year's spending had gotten before the mistake was caught, nor would she confirm whether the same spreadsheet had been used, unmodified, for the eight months in question. Asked directly whether anyone had reviewed the revenue projection between its creation in March and Tuesday's discovery, she repeated the phrase "routine review process" three times and ended the call.

Supervisor Wants A Full Accounting

County Board Supervisor Lon Dietrich said he learned about the error from a text message forwarded by a colleague Tuesday night and has requested the full reconciliation worksheet ahead of Friday's meeting. "Eight months is a long time for a decimal point to just sit there," Dietrich said. "I've got constituents asking me if this means their tax bill changes, and right now I can't tell them anything, because nobody's told me anything either."

Dietrich said he intends to ask at Friday's meeting whether the county's financial software flags projections that change by an order of magnitude, and if not, why not. He said he expects the answer to involve the words "legacy system."

A Quiet Friday Ahead

"Eight months is a long time for a decimal point to just sit there."

— Lon Dietrich, Waukesha County Board Supervisor

The emergency meeting, scheduled for 9 a.m. Friday in the County Administration Center, is expected to run long. Grusczynski, who has worked in the Controller's Office for 14 months, said he has been asked to attend to walk the board through how he found the discrepancy, a request that he said has made him more nervous than the error itself. "I keep getting told it's not a big deal that I'm the one presenting," he said. "Everyone who tells me that also looks a little relieved it's me and not them."

County officials have not said whether the $4.6 million figure represents money the county believed it had and does not, or money it has and did not know about. Pilch, asked to clarify which direction the error ran, said only that the board would "have full details at the appropriate time" and that residents should not expect any change to services "at this time," a phrase she used twice in the same sentence.

Share this story: