Sports Bars Navigate Dual Wisconsin Losses; Inventory Restocked With 'Consolation Appetizers'
Wisconsin football fell to Maryland 24-21 Saturday, days after women's basketball lost to Green Bay 81-76, forcing local viewing venues into contingency mode.
WAUKESHA — The Dugout Tavern on Sunset Drive went through 38 pounds of chicken wings and two full cases of mozzarella sticks Saturday afternoon, a number manager Debbie Kowalczyk, 44, called "not unusual for a Badgers game" but "unusually joyless" once Maryland sealed a 24-21 win with 1:52 left on the clock.
It was the second disappointing scoreboard the bar's regulars had absorbed in five days. Wisconsin's women's basketball team lost to Green Bay 81-76 the previous Tuesday, a game Kowalczyk said drew "a smaller but somehow more devastated" crowd of 22 people, most of whom stayed through the final buzzer out of what she described as obligation rather than hope.
Snack Contingency Protocols
Kowalczyk said the back-to-back results triggered what she's taken to calling, without irony, "unexpected emotional overhead" among staff, who had scheduled a normal Saturday prep order of 25 pounds of wings before revising it upward Friday night on a hunch.
"You start to feel it in the kitchen before you feel it on the scoreboard. We went through the mozzarella sticks by the end of the third quarter, which almost never happens before a loss like that. The appetizers knew."
— Debbie Kowalczyk, manager, The Dugout Tavern
The Dugout has since placed a standing order with its food distributor for an additional 15 pounds of wings per week through the rest of the football season, a line item Kowalczyk's spreadsheet now labels "consolation inventory."
O'Leary's Reports A Quieter Version Of The Same Problem
Four blocks away, O'Leary's saw a similar pattern during Tuesday's basketball loss, though with less fanfare. Server Tyler Voss, 26, said the bar's usual Tuesday crowd of regulars ordered appetizers at roughly the same rate as any other night, even as the energy in the room flattened out by halftime. Voss said the kind of week where profit margins shrink but appetizer consumption stays steady is one the staff has started to recognize by feel, somewhere between the second missed free throw and the first basket of cheese curds returning to the kitchen for a reorder.
O'Leary's did not adjust its food order ahead of Saturday's football game, a decision Voss said in hindsight "probably should have gone the other way," given that the bar ran out of its listed hot sauce options by the start of the fourth quarter and was down to a single bottle of the mild variety by the final whistle.
A Regular Weighs His Options
Cody England, a south side resident and Dugout regular who watched Saturday's game from his usual table near the back corner, ordered an extra basket of wings around the two-minute warning, a decision made before Maryland's go-ahead score but one he did not walk back afterward. England spent much of the fourth quarter weighing aloud to his table whether the week represented "strategic recalibration" for both programs or simply a run of bad luck that happened to land on the same seven days.
He did not reach a conclusion before the final whistle, according to Kowalczyk, who said England's table ultimately ordered a second basket of wings around the time Maryland's kicker lined up for what turned out to be an unnecessary field goal attempt.
Looking Ahead
Both bars said they plan to keep elevated appetizer inventory on hand through at least the next two Wisconsin football games, regardless of outcome, on the theory that the snacks are now cheaper to have on hand than to explain the lack of. Kowalczyk said The Dugout is also considering adding a second fryer, a capital expense she has started referring to internally as "recession-proof," though she declined to specify what recession she meant.
Neither bar has made changes to its drink specials, which both managers said remain calibrated to a Badgers win, a circumstance Kowalczyk said the bar "has not needed to think about much this fall."
