Electrician Buys 5,000-Square-Foot Industrial Building; Neighbors Begin Speculating On Purpose

The property acquisition near the airport has left observers divided between expansion, investment, and a drag strip rumor nobody can source.

Modern Industrial Warehouse with Freight Vehicle
The building sat on the market for 94 days before closing. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — Kevin Rothstein, a licensed electrician who has run a solo contracting business out of a Grange Avenue garage for 12 years, closed last Thursday on a 5,000-square-foot industrial building near the Waukesha County Airport, and his new neighbors have spent the week since trying to figure out why.

The building, a beige steel-sided structure on Aviation Drive with three overhead bay doors and a gravel lot that fits, by one count, 14 vehicles, had been listed for 94 days before Rothstein's offer went through. County records show the purchase price but not his intentions, a gap that has proven impossible for the surrounding block to leave alone.

Rothstein did not return three calls placed by this reporter over four days, the last of which went to voicemail on a mailbox that was, as of Tuesday, still full.

The Theories Take Shape

Denise Falk, who lives two doors down in a ranch house she has owned since 1991, said she first assumed the building would become a second contracting shop. By Monday she had revised that estimate twice.

"First I thought it was storage for his vans. Then my husband said maybe he's renting bays out to other guys. Now I don't know, and frankly it's all we talk about at dinner."

— Denise Falk, neighbor

Tom Yurkiewicz, who owns the lot directly across Aviation Drive and runs a small engine repair business there, said he counted four different vehicles in the gravel lot over the weekend, none of them marked with Rothstein's business name, which he could not recall despite having seen it on a van for over a decade.

"It's just a name and 'Electric,' I think," Yurkiewicz said. "Could be his name. Could be something else entirely. I've never had reason to write it down."

A Building With A Past

The property last housed a company that refinished boat propellers, which closed in 2024 after its owner retired to Door County. Before that, county permit records list a brief 2019 tenancy by a firm identified only as "aviation parts, unspecified," which never installed signage and left no further trace.

Listing agent Carla Mertens, who represented the seller, said the building drew six showings over its three months on the market, four of them from contractors and two from what she described as "people who just wanted to see inside an industrial building, which happens more than you'd think."

"I can tell you the square footage and the ceiling height, which is 16 feet at the peak. I cannot tell you what Mr. Rothstein plans to do with it, because he never told me either, and I didn't ask twice."

— Carla Mertens, listing agent

No Permits Filed Yet

A check of city permit filings as of Wednesday showed no applications tied to the Aviation Drive address since the sale closed. City zoning records confirm the parcel is already approved for light industrial and contractor storage use, meaning no variance would be needed to simply park vans there and call it a day.

Falk called the lack of filings "either very boring or extremely suspicious, and I can't decide which."

That hasn't stopped the speculation from drifting further afield. Yurkiewicz said his wife has floated a theory involving subleased bays for other solo tradespeople priced out of smaller garage spaces around the county, which he called "the only one that's made me stop laughing." A third neighbor, who declined to be named because he said he didn't want to "be the guy quoted being wrong," said he'd heard a rumor involving a private drag strip, which he admitted made no sense given the building has no adjoining land for one.

For now, the building sits with its overhead doors closed and its gravel lot holding a rotating handful of vehicles that neighbors continue to log, unofficially, in a shared text thread Falk started the day after closing. She said the thread has 11 members and has produced no answers, only increasingly specific guesses.

"At this point we're just watching the lot like it's a nature documentary," Falk said. "Eventually something's going to happen. We just don't know what."

Share this story: