County Tightens Recycling Rules; Backslide Way Handbook Obsolete In Days

Waukesha County's new contamination guidelines render 23 of Kevin Jablonski's 76 handbook pages inaccurate, three weeks after he finished writing them.

Overflowing Trash Bin
The county says the change affects roughly a third of all household recycling bins countywide. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — Kevin Jablonski, 52, learned Thursday that Waukesha County had tightened its plastics recycling guidelines to accept only container types 1 through 4, down from the 1-through-7 standard he had spent 11 hours researching before releasing a 76-page handbook to 47 neighbors on Nov. 2.

By his own count, completed Friday morning at his kitchen table with a highlighter and a cup of coffee he described as his third, 23 of the handbook's 76 pages are now inaccurate. Chapter 9, "Plastic Numbering: A Field Guide," is the hardest hit, with four of its six pages dedicated to types 5 through 7 that the county no longer accepts curbside.

The Phone Call

Jablonski said he first heard about the change from Darlene Oskey, the Backslide Way neighbor who received the original handbook and later told him she'd seen a segment about the county's new guidelines on the Thursday evening news. "She called and said, 'Did you know,' and I said, 'Know what,' and she said, 'Chapter 9,' and I had to sit down," Jablonski said.

He said he spent that evening cross-referencing the county's new one-page notice against his own document and found that the notice, released with an effective date of Nov. 16, covers in roughly 140 words what his handbook addressed across six pages, a comparison he said he found "humbling, but not persuasive enough to make me think the six pages were unnecessary."

"I don't think the handbook was wrong when I wrote it. I think the handbook was correct for three weeks, which is more than some things last around here."

— Kevin Jablonski, Backslide Way resident

Why The County Changed Course

Carla Dietzler, outreach coordinator for the Waukesha County Solid Waste Management Division, said the narrower plastics list follows changes at the regional materials recovery facility that sorts the county's recycling, which stopped accepting types 5 through 7 after the equipment that separates them broke down twice in six weeks and was not replaced.

"We understand the timing is frustrating for residents who had just gotten comfortable with the old list," Dietzler said, adding that the division had not been aware of Jablonski's handbook prior to being contacted for this story. Asked whether the county had considered giving residents more notice, Dietzler said the division "moved as quickly as the facility situation required" and that a mailer explaining the change would arrive at households "within the billing cycle."

Neighbors Adjust, Some More Than Others

Oskey said she had already thrown out the yogurt tub she'd been saving specifically because Jablonski's handbook told her it was fine, a type-5 container she now understands to be contaminating her bin as of Nov. 16. "I kept it on the counter for nine days out of principle," she said. "Now the principle is gone and I just have a yogurt tub."

Ned England, who lives two doors down and said he never finished reading the handbook in the first place, said the news didn't affect him because he sorts his recycling "by eye, from the porch," a method unrelated to any numbering system. He said he'd already heard about the county's change from his son Trevor, who mentioned it in passing, and that he planned to keep doing what he's been doing, which he described only as "working so far."

An Addendum, Again

Jablonski said he is setting aside the shredded-paper-and-broken-glass addendum he had planned to distribute this week in order to prioritize a correction to Chapter 9, which he intends to call "Chapter 9, Revised: What We Thought We Knew." He estimated the correction at four to six pages and said he plans to post it to Nextdoor as a reply to his original six-part thread rather than starting a new one, "so people can see the whole timeline if they want to, which I think is actually kind of interesting now."

He said he has not decided whether to print the correction on its own paper or ask the 47 original recipients to physically cross out the outdated sections of their copies by hand. "I'm leaning toward cross out," he said. "It feels more honest about what happened."

Deputy City Clerk Lorna Petraitis, who reviewed the original handbook for comment two weeks ago, said the City Clerk's office had already begun fielding resident questions about the county's new plastics list and would update its own website guidance "as soon as the county's mailer gives us something official to link to."

The county's new guidelines take effect Nov. 16. Jablonski's correction does not yet have a deadline.

Share this story: