Judge Specifies No Brewers Hats In Chambers After Three Consecutive Mistrials

A county court clarified dress code policies after World Series celebration attire was blamed for stalling jury deliberations twice in one week.

Urban Display of Classic Baseball Jerseys
The memo runs four pages and includes a diagram. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — The Waukesha County Circuit Court issued a memo Thursday afternoon specifying exactly which pieces of Brewers championship apparel are and are not acceptable inside courtrooms, following two consecutive jury deliberations that ended in mistrials this week after jurors reportedly lost focus over what court staff described as celebratory attire worn by spectators in the gallery.

The memo, distributed to all court personnel and posted in three courthouse hallways, lists 47 items of what it calls "permissible celebratory attire" and 12 items explicitly banned, including Brewers jerseys of any size, championship caps, and what the document describes as "foam fingers of all varieties, regardless of intended wearer."

Court administrator Denise Okafor, who drafted the memo alongside the clerk's office over two days, said the document was not meant to dampen civic enthusiasm but to keep proceedings on schedule.

"We are thrilled for the Brewers. We are less thrilled about a 46-minute jury deliberation turning into a conversation about ring designs."

— Denise Okafor, Waukesha County court administrator

What went wrong Tuesday

According to courthouse staff, Tuesday's mistrial in a civil dispute over a fence line began unraveling around minute 30, when three spectators seated in the back row of the gallery were noticed wearing matching World Series commemorative caps with the tags still attached. Bailiff Carl Yaeger, a 14-year veteran of courthouse security, said the jury's attention "left the building entirely" shortly after.

"One of the jurors in seat four turned around twice in under a minute. By the time deliberations started, half the panel wanted to know where the hats were purchased, not whether the fence was two feet over the property line."

— Carl Yaeger, Waukesha County courthouse bailiff

Yaeger said he personally counted 11 instances of jurors glancing toward the gallery during the final 20 minutes of proceedings before the judge called a recess. The case was declared a mistrial at 4:12 p.m. and is scheduled to be reheard in December.

The banned list

Beyond jerseys, caps and foam fingers, the memo's banned list includes rally towels larger than 11 by 18 inches, any item that "makes a sound when shaken," temporary championship tattoos visible above the collar, and what the memo refers to only as "the inflatable bat, singular, confiscated Monday." Permissible items include lapel pins, discreet wristbands, and a single commemorative button no larger than two inches in diameter, which may be worn "without comment from the bench."

Okafor said the 47-item permissible list took longer to compile than the 12-item banned list because staff kept finding edge cases. A commemorative scarf was debated for 20 minutes before being approved on the condition it not be worn as a headband.

Juror reaction

Louis Treptow, who served as foreperson on Wednesday's panel in an unrelated small-claims matter and said he was aware of the new memo before entering the courtroom, called the policy reasonable.

"I had a cap in my car. I left it there," Treptow said. "Honestly it was a relief not to think about it. You can only evaluate a dispute over a shared driveway for so long before your mind wanders to the bullpen."

Court officials said the memo will remain in effect through the end of the World Series parade season, with a review scheduled for late November to determine whether any provisions should become permanent. Okafor said the two-page diagram illustrating acceptable button placement has already been requested by two other Wisconsin county courts for their own reference.

No further mistrials have been reported since the memo was distributed Thursday, though Yaeger said he confiscated one foam finger from a spectator's coat pocket Friday morning "just to be safe."

Share this story: