Red Kettle Season Opens; City Logistics Staff Now Arbitrate Intersection Disputes

Three neighborhood associations want dedicated kettle corners, and a municipal coordinator is stuck doing the math.

Vintage Holiday Bell with Snowy Pine
A Salvation Army kettle stand at a downtown Waukesha intersection. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — The Salvation Army's annual Red Kettle campaign kicked off this week with a $1 million fundraising goal, but the organization's biggest logistical headache this year has nothing to do with money. It has to do with corners.

Three separate neighborhood associations have filed formal requests with the city asking for dedicated kettle placement at specific intersections, forcing a municipal logistics coordinator into a role nobody budgeted for: traffic-and-charity mediator.

Randy Phasko, 44, who normally spends his days scheduling snowplow routes and street-sweeping rotations, was pulled into the dispute two weeks ago after the South Side Neighborhood Alliance submitted a three-page letter citing what it called "decades of underrepresentation in kettle distribution" along Grand Avenue and Moreland Boulevard.

A Formula Nobody Asked For

The Downtown Residents Coalition countered with its own request for the Main Street and Sunset Drive corner, citing higher foot traffic from Saturday farmers market crowds. A third group, the North Avenue Merchants Association, asked for a rotating schedule so no single business would be seen, in its words, "hosting a monopoly on generosity."

Phasko said he's spent eleven hours building a spreadsheet that weighs foot-traffic counts, estimated bell-ringer shift availability, and proximity to competing collection boxes, including the clear plastic tip jars at two nearby coffee shops.

"Intersection viability is a complex calculus involving foot traffic, competitor proximity and volunteer availability. I did not expect to be running regression analysis on charitable giving in week one of the holiday season, but here we are."

— Randy Phasko, city logistics coordinator

The Roundabout Is Off The Table

One early proposal, floated by the North Avenue Merchants Association, suggested placing a kettle inside the East Avenue roundabout itself to capture drivers idling while they figured out which exit to take. Phasko rejected it within minutes.

"Nobody can navigate that roundabout correctly as it is," Phasko said. "Adding a pedestrian with a kettle and a bell to the equation is not a safety improvement. That proposal is dead on arrival, and I say that with love."

Linda Oskowski, the Salvation Army's Waukesha County unit coordinator, said the organization typically lets individual retail hosts decide on placement and has never before fielded a formal, written request from a neighborhood association, let alone three in the same week.

Mediation Expected To Take Two Weeks

Oskowski said the organization is grateful for the enthusiasm but is trying to stay neutral. "We ring bells. We are not in the business of adjudicating whose block deserves more foot traffic," she said. "That said, if the city wants to build us a spreadsheet, we're not going to say no to a spreadsheet."

Phasko's office has scheduled a mediation session for Nov. 24, with a target resolution date of Dec. 1, two weeks from the initial complaint. He said the current working plan assigns the South Side Neighborhood Alliance the Grand Avenue and Moreland Boulevard corner on weekday afternoons, gives the Downtown Residents Coalition the Main Street and Sunset Drive corner on weekends, and places the North Avenue Merchants Association on a rotating two-week schedule between two secondary locations, pending sign-off from all three groups.

"Every group thinks their corner is the best corner," Phasko said. "I have learned more about pedestrian density in this city in the last two weeks than I have in six years of plowing its streets."

The campaign runs through Christmas Eve. The Salvation Army said it will accept kettle donations at any approved location regardless of which neighborhood association technically requested it first.

Share this story: