Menomonee Falls Pair's 487-Baseball Collection Travels To World Series As 'Comparison Sample Set'

Twelve years and 14,000 miles into their ballpark tradition, a mother and son are bringing 32 of their finest balls along in a climate-controlled case.

A row of baseballs displayed in a foam-lined case.
Thirty-two of the 487 balls made the cut for the trip. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — The tradition started in 2014 with one explicit goal: Pam Dorsey and her 16-year-old son, Kyle, would attend a Brewers game and come home with a souvenir baseball. Twelve years, 487 baseballs and roughly 14,000 cumulative miles of driving later, the pair is headed to American Family Field this week for the World Series, and for the first time, they're bringing part of the collection with them.

The case is a 22-inch, foam-lined, climate-controlled unit Kyle built in his garage in New Berlin using a dehumidifier kit originally intended for cigar storage. It holds what the family calls the '32 finest balls,' selected not for sentimental value but for what Pam describes as reference quality.

A spreadsheet comes too

Pam, 56, maintains a shared spreadsheet with 14 columns, including seam wear, scuff density, grass-stain percentage and 'acquisition method' (caught, rolled, thrown by mascot, retrieved from under seat 112). She plans to bring a printed copy to the game in a plastic sleeve.

"You can't grade a new ball against memory. You need the sample set in front of you, under the same lighting conditions if possible."

— Pam Dorsey, collection co-founder

Kyle, now 28 and a contractor, has spent the last decade refining what he calls his 'catch zone' theory, which holds that right field, specifically sections 216 through 220, offers the highest probability of an airborne souvenir based on left-handed batting tendencies and bullpen proximity. He has purchased tickets in that section for 112 of the family's 140 games attended.

He estimates the hobby has cost the family about $8,400 in gas alone, a figure he arrived at using fuel receipts dating back to a 2016 Waukesha County gas station loyalty app he still has installed on an otherwise retired phone. He declined to estimate ticket costs, calling that 'a separate and more painful spreadsheet.'

The case clears security, barely

Getting a locked display case containing three dozen baseballs through stadium security required two phone calls and one laminated letter, which Kyle wrote himself, explaining the case's contents and intended comparison use. Security ultimately allowed it through as a 'personal display item,' though staff did run it through the X-ray machine twice.

Kyle has also packed a soft-sided insert bag for any new acquisitions, pre-labeled with a blank condition-grade field so a ball can be assessed on-site before being added to the official count later. 'You don't want to grade under stadium lighting and then regrade at home,' he said. 'The numbers won't match.'

No ball left behind

The family's standards have tightened over the years. A ball retrieved in 2018 that Pam initially logged as 'mint' was later downgraded to 'very good' after Kyle noticed a thumbnail-sized grass stain that had gone unnoticed for four months. The ball remains in the main collection, stored at the family's house in Menomonee Falls, but did not make the cut for this week's traveling case.

"We don't throw anything out. We just reclassify."

— Kyle Dorsey, collection co-founder

Whatever ball or balls the pair come home with this week will be assessed against the 32-ball reference set before being assigned a permanent spreadsheet row. Pam said she's hopeful, but not demanding, that the trip produces 'something north of 489 total.'

Share this story: