Airport Rental Counter Pre-Issues Warning: Book World Series Trips Now
Waukesha County Airport's car rental desk says travelers who wait past three weeks out will get stuck with the SUVs nobody wanted in March.
WAUKESHA — The rental car counter at Waukesha County Airport has started telling callers something before they even ask: book now, or get used to the idea of a Dodge Durango.
Counter manager Phyllis Reitmeyer said her staff began fielding Brewers-related rental questions on Oct. 19 and noticed a pattern fast enough that she wrote a script. Callers ask about availability for a date range tied to the World Series. Staff now answer before the caller finishes the sentence.
"We used to wait for people to ask about compacts. Now we just tell them up front, the compacts are gone in your head whether you know it or not, so book 21 days out or start getting comfortable with an SUV you didn't want."
— Phyllis Reitmeyer, rental counter manager
The 21-day line
Reitmeyer's 21-day advisory is based on a six-car compact fleet and a four-car mid-size fleet, both of which she said are already down to single-digit holds for the first two weeks of November. She declined to say how many cars are reserved under names she recognized as coworkers' relatives, saying only that it was 'more than zero and fewer than six.'
Reservations staffer Dale Kowalczyk, 34, said he has personally talked eleven people out of a Chevy Suburban in the last nine days by describing, unprompted, what it is like to parallel park one on Broadway during a train stoppage. Four of the eleven booked a compact instead. Three asked if Uber worked out here. The remaining four hung up without saying anything, which Kowalczyk logs as a 'soft no.'
What's left on the lot
By Reitmeyer's count, the counter has 14 compacts, 9 mid-size sedans, and 21 SUVs or minivans bookable for World Series weekend as of Tuesday. She said the SUV number has not moved because nobody wants to drive a Chrysler Pacifica to a baseball game, a sentence she said out loud to three separate customers this week without anyone disagreeing.
The counter has also begun quoting a specific rideshare alternative to anyone who calls after the 21-day window has closed on their travel date. Kowalczyk said he tells late callers that a round trip between the airport and American Family Field runs 'somewhere between $38 and the price of dignity,' depending on surge pricing he cannot control and does not apologize for.
The upgrade offer
Reitmeyer said the upgrade offer itself is not a trick, just arithmetic. Once the compact and mid-size lots are booked, the only vehicles physically present are the larger ones, and the counter is contractually required to rent out what is on the lot. She said she has stopped calling it an 'upgrade' internally and started calling it 'the inventory you get for waiting,' a phrase she road-tested on four customers Monday and found none of them enjoyed.
Shuttle driver Theo Brandt, 26, said he has started warning arriving passengers about the compact shortage during the walk from baggage claim to the rental counter, a journey of roughly 90 seconds he has stretched to two minutes by walking slower and talking faster.
"By the time we get to the counter they already know. I just want them to hear it from a human being first, not from Phyllis."
— Theo Brandt, shuttle driver
Booking without a game ticket
Reitmeyer said roughly a third of this week's calls came from people who do not yet have World Series tickets but want a car reserved regardless, on the theory that a car is easier to get rid of than a flight. She said the counter has no policy against this and will happily hold a Toyota Corolla for a game that may or may not happen in Milwaukee, though she noted the hold does not include any opinion on the Brewers' chances, which she keeps to herself at work.
Travelers driving to the games rather than flying may want a cargo organizer (paid link) to keep tailgate gear from sliding around in whatever is left on the lot. Reitmeyer said she has no stake in what people pack, only in when they call.
As of Tuesday afternoon, the counter's 21-day window for the earliest possible World Series dates had already closed. Reitmeyer said she plans to leave the advisory running through the end of the series regardless, on the theory that somebody, somewhere, still hasn't called.
