Realtor Shows Three Backslide Way Listings Despite Market Downturn; Prices "Remain Optimistic," Agent Says
Karen Brennan is marketing three homes on Backslide Way even as October sales volume drops and prices climb in what she calls an apparent contradiction.
WAUKESHA — Real estate agent Karen Brennan has three homes listed on Backslide Way right now, and she would like everyone to know that she is aware this is a strange time to have three homes listed on Backslide Way.
County sales data released last week showed October closings down 19 percent from the same month a year ago, even as median asking prices in the Backslide Way corridor climbed for the third straight month. Brennan, a 38-year veteran of the Waukesha market, said she has never seen the two numbers move in opposite directions this hard for this long.
"The market feels stuck between two incompatible facts," Brennan said. "Fewer people are buying, but the people who are buying are paying more. I've stopped trying to explain it to clients and started just telling them the numbers and letting them sit with it."
Three Houses, Three Price Points
The listings, at 412, 418 and 426 Backslide Way, range from $285,000 to $465,000. Brennan said she priced all three at what she called "competitive rates for the neighborhood," a phrase she repeated four times over the course of a 20-minute phone interview, each time with what a reporter described as identical inflection.
The middle listing, 418 Backslide Way, is a three-bedroom ranch that backs up to the rear fence line of Ned England's duplex two doors down. England, 70, said he has already fielded three separate requests from open-house visitors asking where they could park without blocking his driveway, a question he said he answers the same way every time.
"I tell them the street, not the driveway, and most of them listen," England said. "The ones who don't, I note the time and the vehicle. Nothing's come of it yet this month."
Back-To-Back Open Houses
Brennan has scheduled open houses at all three properties for Saturday, running from noon to 2 p.m., 2:30 to 4:30 p.m., and 5 to 7 p.m. respectively, a sequence she described as deliberate rather than accidental. She said she expects foot traffic to be "modest at best" given the sales numbers, but added that modest traffic is still traffic.
"I've done worse Saturdays with better numbers behind me," Brennan said. "At least right now I know what I'm dealing with."
Brennan's colleague at the brokerage, Stan Oleniczak, said he has been tracking the same county data and has a theory he described as "informal." Oleniczak, who has worked alongside Brennan for 11 years, said he believes the market will "stabilize" sometime in 2027, though he declined to specify a month or cite a source for the prediction.
"I don't have a chart for it," Oleniczak said. "It's more of a feeling I get when I drive past the listings on my way to the office. Call it an informed hunch."
Pricing Stays "Optimistic"
Asked whether the three listings might be repriced downward given the broader slowdown, Brennan said she has no plans to adjust any of the three asking prices before the end of the year. She said she prefers the word "optimistic" to describe where the prices currently sit.
"Optimistic doesn't mean unrealistic," Brennan said. "It means I think the right buyer is still out there, and I'd rather wait for them than chase a number down to meet someone who wasn't going to buy the house anyway."
Brennan said all three Backslide Way listings will remain active through the holidays regardless of Saturday's turnout, and that she has already blocked out a second round of open houses for the second weekend of December "just in case the first round needs a sequel."
