Unseasonably Mild Forecast Forces Retailers To Push Christmas Stock Up Three Weeks

With highs near 65 through Nov. 8, Waukesha stores are shelving holiday inventory that was locked in months before anyone knew the weather would misbehave.

Curious Labrador in Store Aisle
Holiday inventory stacked near the front registers at Target on Grand Avenue, three weeks ahead of its usual appearance. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — The Target on Grand Avenue had moved roughly 70 percent of its holiday merchandise onto the sales floor by Friday, a full three weeks earlier than the chain's typical rollout, after the National Weather Service forecast sunny skies and highs in the mid-60s through Nov. 8.

The store's inventory orders were locked in back in August, long before anyone could have known the first full week of November would feel like early October. With nowhere else to put pallets of artificial wreaths and string lights that were already paid for and already arriving on trucks, the merchandise is going out now, whether or not the thermometer agrees.

Kyle Hollenbeck, a district merchandising supervisor who oversees three Target locations in Waukesha County, said the store doesn't have a separate holding area built for this situation. "We don't have a warehouse where things wait for the weather to catch up," Hollenbeck said. "Once it's on the truck, it needs a shelf. The shelf doesn't know what the sky looks like."

Main Street feels the same squeeze

Downtown, the effect has been smaller but no less disorienting. Denise Kowalczyk, who owns the gift boutique Scraps and Sparks on Main Street, said she put out her first string of ornament displays Thursday, a date she normally reserves for the week after Thanksgiving.

"The warm weather breaks the psychological switch that makes people think Christmas shopping is for November. Nobody's walking past my window in a 64-degree jacket thinking about stocking stuffers."

— Denise Kowalczyk, owner, Scraps and Sparks

Kowalczyk said she's tried compensating by keeping her patio chairs and a rack of light cardigans in the front window alongside the ornaments, a split display she's calling "transitional" to customers who ask why there's tinsel next to a sunhat.

Confusion on Northview Road

At Northview Toy & Hobby on Northview Road, manager Patricia Wysocki said the warmth has done something odder than slow sales: it's scrambled what customers think they're shopping for. She said at least a dozen people this week have walked in asking about Halloween clearance, unaware the store switched its endcaps to holiday gift sets on Oct. 29.

"People are still thinking fall because it feels like fall," Wysocki said. "I had a man ask me Tuesday if we had any more light-up pumpkins. I pointed at the nutcracker display and he just kind of nodded and left." Wysocki said she's resisted the urge to put the pumpkins back out, on the theory that reversing course now would only confuse the inventory system further.

No relief until the system changes

Hollenbeck said corporate has not given Grand Avenue permission to slow the rollout further, noting that spring merchandise is already scheduled to begin arriving behind the holiday shipment in early December regardless of what November does. He said the store's planogram, the diagram dictating exactly which shelf holds which product on which date, was finalized before the forecast existed and can't be revised without a regional sign-off that typically takes two weeks.

"If it snowed tomorrow, we'd look like we planned it," Hollenbeck said. "It's not going to snow tomorrow."

Kowalczyk said she's considered marking down a rack of insulated gloves early just to make room, but worries it will look strange to sell winter gear at a discount while it's 64 degrees outside. For now, both stores say they'll keep stocking the calendar instead of the thermometer, and wait for the weather to eventually agree with the shelves.

Share this story: