Brewers Merchandise Vanishes From Local Shelves; Reorders Already Underway
A West Avenue sporting goods store sold six weeks of Brewers inventory in 48 hours and still can't get hats.
WAUKESHA — Six weeks of Brewers merchandise disappeared from the shelves of Baseline Sporting Goods on West Avenue in 48 hours this week, and store manager Carl Dietzler said Thursday he has given up trying to predict when more hats will arrive.
"I had 94 fitted caps on Tuesday morning. By Wednesday night I had four, and three of those were extra-large," Dietzler said, standing in front of a hat wall that now holds mostly empty pegs and a single foam finger. "We've never had to reorder this fast. Usually I'm reordering in March for the next September."
The depletion follows the Brewers' World Series victory and has hit nearly every retailer in the city carrying licensed gear, from sporting goods stores to gas station convenience racks. Dietzler said his distributor, which normally ships Brewers product within a day, is now quoting a three-to-five day backlog because of what the supplier described in an email as "unprecedented regional demand" across Wisconsin.
The gas station angle
Corner Stop, the convenience store chain with a location on Sunset Drive, has placed what regional supervisor Denise Okafor called a "priority restock order" after its single spinning rack of Brewers gear emptied out by Tuesday evening. Okafor said the Sunset Drive store moved 61 items off that rack in one day, more than the location typically sells in a quarter.
"We had a guy buy all four remaining youth shirts because he said he'd sort out which kid gets which size later," Okafor said. "We don't usually have to think about rationing a spinner rack."
Corner Stop's distribution center in Pewaukee has reportedly reassigned two pallets originally destined for a Michigan location to Waukesha County stores instead, a decision Okafor described only as "above my job description, but I'm not complaining."
Secondary market pressure
Dietzler said the shortage has pushed a handful of customers toward resale apps, where he's seen Waukesha-area listings for championship t-shirts priced at nearly triple retail. He said he's declined to comment on whether any of that inventory originated from his own store's stockroom before the public restock, other than to say, "I keep good count."
"We've never had to reorder this fast. Usually I'm reordering in March for the next September."
— Carl Dietzler, manager, Baseline Sporting Goods
Baseline has resorted to a waitlist system for the fitted caps, a clipboard taped to the register where customers write their name, phone number and preferred size. Dietzler said the list had 112 names on it by Thursday morning, and he's warned everyone on it that the next shipment, whenever it arrives, is unlikely to cover more than half the list.
No end date in sight
Okafor said Corner Stop's corporate office has not given franchisees a firm restock date, only guidance to "manage expectations." Dietzler said he's told his staff to stop quoting delivery windows to customers entirely after a shipment he promised for "end of the week" three weeks ago never materialized, a timeline he now attributes to a clerical mixup rather than any reflection on supply.
For now, both stores are directing disappointed customers toward whatever stock remains in odd sizes and colors. Dietzler said the extra-large fitted caps aren't moving nearly as fast as the mediums and larges, and he's begun suggesting them to customers as a Brewers championship cap (paid link) alternative if they're willing to size down with an adjustable strap insert.
"I'm not saying it's the same as getting the fitted one you wanted," Dietzler said. "I'm saying it's a hat, and it exists, and I have twelve of them."
