Local Restaurants Say Brewers Promotions Have Cut Profit Margins To 'Virtually Nothing'

Ten days of free wings and half-price appetizers tied to the Brewers' World Series run have left downtown bars breaking even during their best week of the year.

Modern Mediterranean Bar Interior
A tray of complimentary wings heads to a packed bar top on West Avenue. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — The Rail Yard Tap on West Avenue has given away an estimated $4,200 worth of free wings, half-price appetizers and commemorative pint glasses over the past ten days, and manager Mike Delveccio said the bar's books now show something close to nothing.

"If the Brewers had lost, we'd be showing actual black ink on our ledgers," Delveccio said, flipping through a stack of receipts he keeps in a binder labeled, in handwriting, "DO NOT THROW OUT - TAX GUY." "Instead we're up 340 percent on foot traffic and basically flat on profit. It's the best worst two weeks of my career."

The promotions, rolled out the night the Brewers clinched their National League Championship Series berth, were meant to capture a few extra rounds of celebratory foot traffic. Free wings on victory nights. Half off mozzarella sticks during games. A buy-one-get-one on commemorative 16-ounce cups shaped, loosely, like the stadium's retractable roof. Nobody budgeted for the Brewers winning every single game they played.

The math got worse by the inning

Delveccio said the original promotion was built around a model in which the Brewers lost at least one World Series game, giving the bar a natural night off from giveaways to recoup. That game never happened. The team swept, and the Rail Yard Tap honored every single-night promotion it had announced, including a Game 4 offer of a free basket of cheese curds for anyone wearing a Brewers jersey, which Delveccio said covered roughly 85 percent of the room by the second inning.

Across town, Froth & Flame on East Broadway ran a similar bet. Co-owner Denise Kowalczyk said she authorized a promotion offering a free beer flight to any table that ordered an entree during a Brewers win, expecting maybe two or three qualifying nights. The team won six straight to close out the Series, and Kowalczyk said the restaurant poured 1,140 ounces of complimentary beer in a single ten-day stretch, a number she has since had laminated and taped above the keg cooler as a warning to future self.

An accountant weighs in

Paul Rechsteiner, a CPA who handles books for three downtown Waukesha restaurants, said he has reviewed the Rail Yard Tap's October ledger twice because he assumed the first pass contained an error. It did not. Rechsteiner said the bar's net margin for the period landed at 0.6 percent, a figure he described as technically profitable and functionally a rounding error, and recommended that any future promotion include a loss-limiting clause tied to a team's actual win-loss record rather than a manager's optimism.

Rechsteiner added that he has advised at least one client to build next year's playoff promotions around a losing scenario instead, on the theory that Waukesha diners will show up for a losing team's commiseration specials just as reliably as a winning team's celebration specials, and at considerably less cost to the house.

Crowds aren't going anywhere

Despite the thin margins, both Delveccio and Kowalczyk said they have no plans to end the promotions before the city's planned championship parade route is finalized. Delveccio said foot traffic has been high enough that the bar sold through its entire stock of commemorative cups twice and had to reorder a third batch, a fact he said is good for business even if it does not currently show up as a dollar figure anywhere on his bank statement.

Kowalczyk said Froth & Flame will keep the beer-flight promotion running through any parade-related events, though she has quietly renamed the internal spreadsheet tracking it from "Brewers Promo" to "Brewers Promo (Final Answer, Stop Extending It)." She said the restaurant remains, in her words, "gloriously, stupidly busy," and that she would make the same bet again.

Share this story: