Traffic Committee Advances E-Bike Rules After 47-Minute Sidewalk Debate
The city's Traffic and Parking Committee voted 4-1 to send e-bike and e-scooter regulations to council, with one member objecting over scooter classification.
WAUKESHA — The city's Traffic and Parking Committee voted 4-1 Monday night to advance a new framework governing e-bikes and e-scooters to the full Common Council, clearing the measure only after a 47-minute debate over whether an e-scooter legally qualifies as a bicycle under the proposed ordinance's language.
The framework, drafted by the city engineering office over the past four months, would permit both e-bikes and e-scooters on a designated network of routes connecting downtown to Frame Park and several residential corridors on the city's east side. Committee chair Renata Kowalczyk said the rules were modeled on frameworks already adopted in two unnamed similarly sized Wisconsin cities, though she declined to say which ones, citing only that staff had "looked around."
A Scooter Is Not A Bike, Argues One Councilman
The dispute that consumed most of the meeting centered on Section 4, Subsection C of the draft ordinance, which defines "bicycle" for purposes of route eligibility. Councilman Gary Puchalski, the lone dissenting vote, argued that the ordinance's definition improperly folds e-scooters into the same category as e-bikes despite what he called "a fundamentally different relationship to the sidewalk."
"This committee has spent four months on where these things can ride and not one minute on where they can stop existing, which is the sidewalk, full stop."
— Gary Puchalski, city councilman
Puchalski said he had personally measured the width of the sidewalk outside the Five Points intersection with a tape measure Sunday afternoon, arriving at 6 feet 2 inches, which he said was insufficient to accommodate "a stroller, a dog on a retractable leash, and an e-scooter going the speed this ordinance implicitly allows." He requested the committee table the vote until staff produced a sidewalk-specific appendix. The request failed 4-1.
City engineer Todd Varney, who presented the framework, said sidewalk riding is already prohibited downtown under an existing 2019 ordinance and that the new framework does not alter that rule, a point he said he made "three separate times" during the meeting. Varney told the committee the framework's main addition is a formal route map, color-coded in a handout that committee member Phyllis Garceau said she found "genuinely hard to read" under the meeting room's overhead lighting.
Forty-Seven Minutes, By The Clerk's Clock
City clerk Darlene Ottoson, who timestamps agenda items for the official minutes, confirmed the sidewalk discussion ran from 7:12 p.m. to 7:59 p.m., a 47-minute span she noted was longer than the committee's discussion of its entire $340,000 pothole repair allocation earlier in the same meeting, which took 11 minutes.
Committee member Hal Bremer, who voted in favor of advancing the framework, said he sympathized with Puchalski's concerns but did not believe a tape-measure reading of one intersection justified further delay. "Gary's not wrong that the sidewalk is narrow," Bremer said. "But the sidewalk was that narrow before e-scooters existed, and we didn't convene an emergency committee about strollers."
Resident Carl Dziedzic, who addressed the committee during public comment, said he supported the framework primarily because it would finally give him a legal route to ride an e-bike from his home on Northview Road to his job at a downtown insurance office without crossing what he described as "four blocks I currently do illegally and feel bad about." Dziedzic said he owns a folding e-bike (paid link) he purchased specifically anticipating the new rules, and that he has been riding it on sidewalks "against my better judgment" since August.
What Happens Next
The framework now advances to the full Common Council, which is expected to take it up next month. Puchalski said he intends to reintroduce his sidewalk-width appendix request as a floor amendment, though he acknowledged he does not currently have the votes. Varney said the engineering office will, in the meantime, attempt to produce a higher-contrast version of the route map.
Kowalczyk, asked after the meeting whether she expected the sidewalk debate to resurface at the council level, said only that she had "budgeted emotionally for that likelihood."
