City Advises Trick-Or-Treating Wrap By 7 P.M. Ahead Of Badgers Kickoff

Waukesha Parks and Recreation issued a Halloween advisory this week recommending families finish before the Badgers-Iowa kickoff at Kinnick Stadium.

Child Walking at Sunset in Halloween Pajamas
The department's advisory did not specify what happens to trick-or-treaters still on porches at 7:01. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — The Waukesha Parks and Recreation Department issued a community advisory Thursday recommending that families complete trick-or-treating by 7 p.m. Saturday, citing a scheduling conflict with the Wisconsin Badgers' kickoff against Iowa at Kinnick Stadium.

The advisory, posted to the department's website and shared across several neighborhood Facebook groups, does not change the city's official trick-or-treat window of 5:30 to 8 p.m., but does, in the words of parks spokesperson Carla Dunmore, 46, "gently suggest that families who also care about the Badgers front-load their candy logistics."

"We're not canceling anything," Dunmore said. "We're just acknowledging that a decent chunk of this city is going to be doing math on a Saturday afternoon, and we'd rather give them the numbers early than have them doing it on a dark porch at 6:50."

A Nextdoor Poll Gets Involved

The advisory arrived days after a Nextdoor poll in the Hillcrest neighborhood asked 83 respondents whether they'd be willing to move trick-or-treating up from the traditional 5:30 p.m. start to 4 p.m. Sixty-seven percent said yes, a result the poll's creator, Denise Ferraro, 39, described as "surprisingly decisive for a group of people who can't agree on leaf pickup."

"An early start means more houses before dark, which is a win regardless of which team wins at Kinnick. I don't even watch football and I voted yes."

— Denise Ferraro, Hillcrest resident

Ferraro said the poll was intended as a casual temperature check, not a binding neighborhood decision, but acknowledged that at least four families on her block have already told her they're starting at 4 p.m. regardless of what their kids' friends on the next street over are doing, which she called "a coordination problem nobody asked me to solve."

Backslide Way Runs Its Own Numbers

On Backslide Way, longtime resident Ned England, 70, said he plans to treat Saturday evening the same way he treats most evenings on his street: from a lawn chair, with a clipboard. England, who normally uses the setup to log speeding hospital traffic, said he intends to time trick-or-treating groups between houses out of what he described as "pure curiosity, nothing official."

"If the city wants everybody done by 7, somebody ought to know the actual pace people are moving at," England said. "Last year I clocked the average stop at ninety seconds, porch to porch, candy bowl to candy bowl. This year I want to see if the Badgers thing speeds anybody up." He said he would not be using the radar gun for this particular project, calling it "not that kind of measurement."

What Happens At 7:01

Dunmore said the department has no plan to station staff at porches to enforce the recommended cutoff, and that families who prefer the traditional 5:30 start and full 8 p.m. window are welcome to ignore the advisory entirely. She said the department's goal was simply to flag the conflict before it became, in her words, "a Saturday night argument in forty different driveways."

"Nobody's candy is getting confiscated at 7," Dunmore said. "We just know how this city feels about Saturdays with the Badgers on, and we didn't want anyone finding out the hard way that their kid's neighborhood route and kickoff don't fit in the same evening."

Dunmore added that the department briefly considered recommending an earlier citywide start time altogether, but decided against it after realizing it would require renegotiating the trick-or-treat window with several neighboring communities, a process she said was "not something we were going to open up over one football game, even a ranked one."

As of Thursday evening, the advisory had not been formally amended, and families on at least three Waukesha streets had already begun privately agreeing to start at 4 p.m. without telling the city.

Share this story: