Krueger: Public Safety Referenda Represent 'Clear Choice Between Security And Uncertainty'

Five separate safety-focused ballot measures have prompted one local opinion contributor to weigh in with his typical ambivalence.

Urban Billboard Scene
Five referenda, one ballot, zero clarity. (Waukesha City News)

WAUKESHA — Tuesday's ballot asks city voters to decide on five separate public safety referenda, covering police station upgrades, new fire equipment, additional EMS staffing, dispatch center improvements and an expansion of traffic cameras at busy intersections. Having read all five measures twice, I can say with confidence that they represent either a clear choice between adequate civic security and reckless under-investment, or an elaborate tax grab depending on your view of government spending. I have not been able to narrow it down further than that.

The police station measure asks for $4.2 million to replace a roof that has been patched eleven times since 2009 and to add a second holding cell, which the department says is necessary and which I am told some residents believe is excessive, though nobody has explained to me what the correct number of holding cells is. The fire equipment referendum is $1.8 million for a new ladder truck to replace the current one, which is 22 years old and whose odometer, a department spokesperson confirmed, 'still works fine, that's not the problem.'

The Harder Ones To Picture

The EMS staffing measure would fund six new full-time paramedic positions, which sounds straightforward until you learn the department currently runs with four part-time paramedics who each work three different departments across the county and one of whom, according to the referendum's own fact sheet, 'is also a volunteer firefighter in Delafield on weekends, which complicates scheduling.' The dispatch center measure is $650,000 for new headsets and a console upgrade, prompted by a 2026 incident in which three calls were briefly routed to the wrong channel for 90 seconds. Nobody was hurt. The console, I am told, was already scheduled for replacement anyway.

The traffic camera expansion would add 14 cameras at intersections the city has identified as high-risk, including two on Sunset Drive that already have a camera but, per the measure's language, 'not currently positioned to capture the angle needed.' I don't know what angle that is. I am told it is a known angle among traffic engineers.

The Guide Nobody Asked For But Everyone Wanted

Diane Vandehey, the county fair planning committee chair who has spent a decade adjudicating the funnel cake versus cream puff dispute with the patience of a woman twice her age, has produced a 16-page color-coded comparison guide to the five referenda on her own time and dropped off copies at the Waukesha Public Library on Monday morning. The library reported the guide is being requested faster than staff can print it, which is either a triumph of civic engagement or a sign the ballot language needs work.

"I color-coded it the same way I color-code the fair's vendor map, green for approved, yellow for pending, red for 'we'll see.' Most of these referenda are yellow. One of them, I won't say which, is red for reasons I'd rather explain in person."

— Diane Vandehey, Waukesha Public Library referendum guide author

I asked a library circulation clerk, Pete Haglund, 34, how many copies had gone out by Monday afternoon. He said 'forty-one, and I had to start a waitlist, which I did not expect to do for a pamphlet about a fire truck.'

Where That Leaves Me

I have voted on referenda before. I voted yes on the 2019 road resurfacing measure and I still think about the stretch of Northview Road it fixed every time I drive it, because it is smooth and I notice smooth pavement the way other men notice cars. But five measures in one sitting is a lot to hold in your head at the voting booth, and I suspect more than a few residents will do what I plan to do, which is vote yes on the ones with trucks in them and remain genuinely torn on the rest.

Greater Milwaukee Today reported this week that Waukesha is not alone in facing a crowded safety-referenda ballot, and that the broader question of whether the state should be funding more of this directly, rather than leaving it to a patchwork of local votes, remains unresolved. I don't have a strong opinion on that either. I have five opinions today and that appears to be my limit.

Polls are open Tuesday from 7 a.m. to 8 p.m. Bring your own sense of certainty. I could not spare mine.

Share this story: