District Weighs Hot Lunch Against Heat As $2.3 Million Budget Gap Forces Choice
Final state aid figures leave the district picking between hot lunch and a working furnace, with a pool full of ducks complicating things further.
WAUKESHA — The School District of Waukesha confirmed Tuesday that a $2.3 million gap in final state aid figures has left administrators choosing between keeping hot lunch service running districtwide or replacing the HVAC system at Waukesha West High School before temperatures drop further, and that a family of mallards currently nesting in the school's pool is not helping.
District spokesperson Carla Deitweiler said the funding shortfall became clear only after the state finalized aid numbers last week, well after the district had already built a budget assuming a smaller cut. 'We had modeled for a bad year,' Deitweiler said. 'We did not model for the ducks also being a line item.'
The ducks, which district facilities staff say have nested in the deep end of the West High School pool since the spring of 2023, complicate any plan to drain the pool for HVAC-related construction access, since the mechanical room sits directly beneath it. Deitweiler said draining the pool outside of nesting season was always part of the original maintenance plan, but this is the third consecutive year the ducks have returned by early April, which district maintenance logs now refer to internally as 'the window closing.'
Lunch Or Furnace, Not Both
According to budget documents presented at Monday night's board session, fully funding hot lunch service for the rest of the school year would cost the district roughly $1.4 million, while replacing the aging boiler system at West would run $2.1 million, more than the entire gap by itself. Board members were told the district cannot do both without pulling from reserve funds the state recently capped at 3% of total budget, down from 8% two years ago.
"Nobody on this board wants to be the name attached to 'voted against lunch.' But nobody wants to be the name attached to 'the furnace died in January' either."
— Carla Deitweiler, district spokesperson
Parent Diane Kowalczyk, who has two children enrolled at West, said she attended Monday's meeting expecting a routine budget update and left with a new understanding of the district's duck policy. 'I came for the furnace,' Kowalczyk said. 'I left knowing there's a mallard named Gerald who has apparently been voted on by name at two prior board meetings.'
The Duck Question, Tabled
District officials declined to attach a dollar figure to any duck-specific accommodation, saying only that the pool drainage schedule would be revisited 'once the lunch and HVAC lines are settled,' tentatively in November. Facilities director Owen Prahl said the ducks are not, strictly speaking, a budget line, but have functioned as one in every planning conversation since 2023. 'They don't have a cost code,' Prahl said. 'They have a cost code adjacent to them.'
Prahl added that the district has looked into relocating the nest earlier in the season in future years, but that the one attempt, in April 2024, resulted in the mother duck returning to the same corner of the pool within 11 minutes, a timeline Prahl said staff now refer to as 'the fastest any district project has ever been completed.'
A Vote Expected By Thanksgiving
Board president Walter Suminski said the board intends to vote on the lunch-versus-HVAC question by its November 24 meeting, giving facilities staff enough lead time to order parts if the HVAC option wins, or enough lead time to notify families if hot lunch service is reduced to three days a week instead of five, which Suminski described as 'the version of this nobody is excited to vote for, but somebody has to.'
Kowalczyk said she plans to attend the November meeting as well, this time with lower expectations for how much of it will be about mallards. 'I've accepted that the duck is now part of the district's identity,' she said. 'I just want the building to be warm while it happens.'
Deitweiler said the district will post updated budget figures to its website once the board votes, and that Gerald, should he return in the spring as expected, will not be included in that document.
