Krueger: Early Holiday Retail Reflects Consumer Intent Or Marketing Desperation
Our observer questions whether retailers' aggressive holiday push signals genuine demand or sector-wide anxiety.
WAUKESHA — I counted fourteen inflatable snowmen between the Piggly Wiggly parking lot and the Walmart on Sunset Drive last Tuesday. Fourteen. It was 61 degrees out, and two of them still had their boxes sitting next to them like the owner hadn't decided whether to commit.
This is the question I keep circling back to: is Waukesha experiencing a genuine wave of holiday enthusiasm, or are we watching a retail sector quietly panic in real time, dressed up in tinsel so nobody notices?
The Weather Isn't Helping Anyone Think Clearly
The mild stretch we've had this fall has let people put up outdoor lights three weeks earlier than usual, which on its own would be a minor curiosity. But it's also given retailers cover to argue that demand, not desperation, is driving the November rollout. Nobody wants to be the manager who waited too long and got stuck holding unsold string lights in a 58-degree December.
Linda Oskowski, who runs a shop downtown, told me she started fielding requests for holiday stock back in mid-October, which she said was new. 'People want it earlier every year, and I don't know if that's them or if that's us training them,' she said. She estimated she'd ordered probably enough to cover it, which, if you've read anything I've written about Linda before, is the answer she gives to most quantities of most things, regardless of category.
I don't say that as a knock. I say it because 'probably enough' might be the most honest assessment anyone in retail has given me all year.
Nobody At City Hall Wants To Touch This
I called the City Clerk's office to ask whether there's any ordinance governing when a resident can legally put up holiday lighting, figuring surely someone had complained about a neighbor's reindeer display showing up before Halloween candy was even off the shelves. There is apparently no such ordinance, and the office has issued no formal guidance on the subject, which I take to mean the city has decided this is a fight it does not want.
That leaves residents and business owners to work it out among themselves, which in Waukesha means roughly half the block decorates the first week of November and the other half waits until after Thanksgiving out of what I can only describe as spite.
"We had the tree section up before we'd finished clearing out the Halloween candy. Corporate says it's 'customer-driven.' I say customers will buy whatever's in front of them in November, same as any other month."
— Mitch Yarnell, seasonal department manager
A Theory, For What It's Worth
My theory, after thirty-some years of watching this town's commercial habits from various vantage points, is that it's both things at once. The demand is real, inasmuch as people genuinely do want to feel something other than dread heading into winter, and buying a wreath in early November scratches that itch cheaply. But the panic is also real, because every retailer in this county remembers at least one year where they guessed wrong on timing and ate the markdown.
So they split the difference. They put the decorations out early enough to catch the optimists, keep the receipts handy in case the whole thing tanks, and let Bob Krueger write six hundred words wondering what it all means.
For what it's worth, I bought one of the inflatable snowmen. Not because I wanted it. Because it was the last one on the shelf, and something about that felt like it was trying to tell me something.
