Krueger: Hemp Regulation Shift Represents 'Either Progress Or Peril' For Local Retailers
Our observer weighs a looming federal hemp rule change and concludes it could go either way, which he considers a useful thing to say out loud.
WAUKESHA — I drove past three hemp retailers on Grand Avenue last Wednesday, and all three had the same hand-lettered sign in the window, more or less: open, for now, call with questions. Nobody I talked to seemed panicked exactly. They seemed like people waiting on a weather report they already suspect isn't going to be good, but haven't been told the exact number yet.
That's the position a lot of small Waukesha retailers are in as federal rules around hemp products head toward some kind of change. I want to be careful here, because I think the honest answer is the boring one: this could represent an important clarification of rules that have been murky for years, or it could represent an unnecessary hardship landing on small businesses that didn't write the law and can't do much about it. I've turned it over for a week now and I can't get it to settle on one side.
Nobody Wants To Guess Out Loud
Donna Rybicki, who's run a shop off Grand Avenue for six years, told me she's stopped speculating with customers about what the new rules will actually require. 'I had a guy ask me straight up if we'd still be open in March,' Rybicki said. 'I told him I genuinely don't know, and that felt better than making something up just to be reassuring.'
I respect that answer more than I'd respect a confident one. Nobody in Waukesha retail has a copy of the final rule, because as far as I can tell nobody anywhere has a copy of the final rule. What they have is a timeline, a lot of trade-association newsletters, and a shared understanding that guessing wrong in either direction, too alarmed or too calm, costs something.
Prepare For Either Scenario, Whatever That Means
I'll say what I think Waukesha retailers should do, which is prepare for either scenario, and I'll admit upfront that I don't have a specific recipe for what that preparation looks like. I don't think anyone fully does yet. Some of it is paperwork. Some of it, from what Rybicki described, is just not restocking certain items in quantities you'd regret if the rule lands hard.
"We're not betting the whole shelf on this going one way. That's really it. That's the whole strategy right now."
— Donna Rybicki, hemp retailer, Grand Avenue
At a hardware-adjacent shop two doors down that carries a small hemp section alongside its regular inventory, manager Pete Zawistowski said he's less worried about his own shelf space and more worried about what happens to the specialty shops that don't have anything else to fall back on. 'If it's just clarification, fine, everybody adjusts their paperwork and moves on,' Zawistowski said. 'If it's a hardship, it's a hardship for the places that only sell this, not for a guy like me who's got forty other things on the wall.'
A Broader Tension, Playing Out Slowly
What I keep landing on is that this is a smaller, more local version of a tension that's bigger than Waukesha: commerce moving at the speed commerce moves, and regulation moving at the speed regulation moves, and the gap between those two speeds getting filled, in the meantime, by shop owners putting hand-lettered signs in their windows because nobody's handed them anything better to say.
I don't think that tension resolves itself by spring, or even by next fall. I think it plays out over the coming months the way these things always do, in increments too small to notice individually, until one day the signs in the windows either come down because the shop's still there, or come down because it isn't. For what it's worth, I'm rooting for the first version. I just don't have a way to promise anyone that's the one they're getting.
