Krueger: Thanksgiving Demands 'Strategic Route Planning' Downtown
A longtime observer offers holiday-week advice for relatives attempting to drive into Waukesha's one-way grid.
WAUKESHA — Every year around this time, I get the same phone call from my brother-in-law in Pewaukee, and every year it goes the same way. He says he is '12 minutes out.' Forty minutes later he calls back from a parking lot behind a shuttered boutique on Broadway, asking why his GPS keeps telling him to turn left onto a street that only goes right.
That is Thanksgiving week in Waukesha. It is not a holiday so much as a four-day driving exam nobody studied for, administered by a downtown grid that has humbled better men than my brother-in-law.
The grid does not care about your plans
For readers lucky enough to live somewhere with a normal grid, I will explain once. Several blocks downtown, including stretches of Broadway and St. Paul Avenue, reverse direction depending on which block you happen to be standing on. A resident who has lived here 38 years can still miss a turn and end up circling the same municipal parking structure three times before giving up and parking at the Piggly Wiggly on Sunset Drive out of spite.
Now introduce a family member from Tomahawk who has never seen a one-way sign in his life, driving a rented minivan with four pies balanced on the third-row seat, trying to get to a house he has visited exactly twice. This is not a recipe for a pleasant Tuesday. This is a recipe for a man abandoning his minivan near the 400 block and walking the rest of the way, pies in hand, muttering about 'whoever designed this.'
"He called me from a bench outside a candle shop, 20 minutes late, carrying two pumpkin pies and refusing to make eye contact with me for the rest of dinner."
— Donna Schlei, 59, hosting six out-of-town relatives this Thanksgiving
There is a workaround, and most people ignore it
I have said this in person to at least 40 people over the years and I will say it again in print, where it can be clipped out and taped to a dashboard: the Newhall Avenue underpass, between West Avenue and Grand Avenue, is the only way to pass beneath the railroad tracks without touching the one-way grid or risking a stopped train. It exists. It has existed the entire time. It is clearly marked. GPS systems routinely ignore it in favor of routing visitors through four blocks of reversing traffic, apparently on principle.
I bring a folded paper map to every Thanksgiving I host, not because I distrust technology in general, but because I distrust it specifically between the hours of noon and 6 p.m. on the Wednesday before Thanksgiving, when half of Waukesha County is simultaneously trying to get somewhere else.
Veteran drivers know to add 15 minutes to any downtown errand this week, minimum. First-timers do not know this, and that is precisely how you can spot them: idling at a green light they are afraid to take because it does not match what their dashboard screen is telling them.
A test with only one lesson
Thanksgiving week separates the people who know this city from the people who are merely visiting it, and the test has exactly one correct answer: take the underpass, ignore the GPS, and budget extra time for the freight train that will, at some point, either cross Broadway in the ordinary 90 seconds or decide to simply stop on the tracks and sit there for a while, for reasons the railroad has never explained to anyone I know.
If you are hosting relatives this week, I recommend calling them the night before with three pieces of information: the Newhall Avenue underpass, the fact that Broadway reverses direction depending on the block, and a warning that the GPS voice, however confident it sounds, has never actually been downtown.
My brother-in-law made it to dinner on time this year, for what I believe is the first time since 2019. He credits the printed directions I mailed him in October. I credit low expectations.
Happy Thanksgiving, and good luck out there.
